Peyton had every right not to like her. So what? Because Lindsey was Lucas' gf Peyton was obligated to like her? I don't think so.
Until 507, the one who chased Peyton was Lucas, not the other way around. Even then, instead of going after his girlfriend Lucas went to see Peyton.
So I don't know how people can say that Peyton was at fault. Lindsey never found out about the kiss, but she also didn't know about "He's not good enough", Lucas questioning his choises and not to mention the ring fiasco...
I agree with this completely.
And I never saw her as a threat to LP. I just couldn't stand her relationship with Lucas. There was zero chemistry and we were just seeing the same scene over and over again. I honestly prefer BL over them.
Yes, Peyton was a complete bitch and completely OOC in Season 5, especially in 5x09, but Lindsay wasn't exactly a saint either. She was threatened by Peyton and by LP and she began to have similar insecurities to what Brooke had in S3.
Plus I don't know if I can ever forgive her about the joke she made about Peyton's gunshot wound/the school shooting. It was lower than anything Peyton said that season and then she didn't even end up apologizing for it. Peyton was the only one who did the apologizing.
I did feel bad for her in a way though. Especially when Lucas blurted out to her that he was getting married in 6x06.. although I was trying hard not to laugh.. haha.